Johnson’s baby、HUGGIES、順順兒、來來寶、萬寧-BB濕紙巾大比拼II

Johnson’s baby、HUGGIES、順順兒、來來寶、萬寧-BB濕紙巾大比拼II


幾乎每個BB每日都會用到濕紙巾,但係之前消委會做過test揭發好多款濕紙巾都含有MIT!如果用左呢d濕紙巾分分鐘對BB健康有威脅。除左健康因素,要考慮嘅仲有「濕度」、「厚度」、「易抽度」、「清潔度」同埋「價錢」!之前Testingmama已經試左好幾款熱門濕紙巾,今次順應民意再試多幾款!e16

(按圖放大)價錢+尺寸+防腐劑列表

1

濕度*+易抽度+堅韌度大測試:

 *片中大力揸張濕紙巾去睇下佢會滴出幾多水係用黎反映佢嘅濕度!即係可以比媽媽睇到當佢用黎抹BB patpat個陣會有幾濕!其實唔出水又唔代表唔夠濕,出得多水又唔代表係好,因為太多水會令到BB尿片區太濕,如果侷住就一定唔好!最緊要係濕度適中,清潔度高!

1.強生嬰兒護膚柔濕巾無香低敏感 Johnson’s baby skincare wipes 80pcs

標榜無香低敏感,含潤膚乳液,新生兒都適用。但靚叻媽覺得一拎上手有d痴立立唔係咁舒服呢!e5

IMG_0263 copy

濕度:大力揸得1滴水出,但就好多泡泡!(因為入面含有乳液)

厚度:star1star1star1star0star0第五厚!

IMG_0265 copy

堅韌度:star1star1star1star1star0延展度高,但扯極唔爛!

易抽度:star1star1star0star0star0抽一張一定會連住下一張

清潔度:star1star1star1star1star1抹2下就可以清走污積

IMG_0266 copy

IMG_0267 copy

清潔用途:潔嬰兒屁股/多用途的產品

成分:Water,Glycerin,Glyceryl Polyacrylate, Coco-Glucoside, Glyceryl Oleate, Lauyl Glucoside, Polyglyceryl-2 Dipolyhydroxystearate, Carbomer, p-Anisic Acid, Phenoxyethanol, Sodium Benzoate, Sodium Hydroxide, Citric Acid

產地:台灣

購買地點:萬寧、屈臣氏、各大藥房

2.順順兒多用途嬰兒濕紙巾 Soondoongi Basic Baby Wet Tissue 40pcs

標榜不含酒精、色素、化角香料、螢光漂白劑、甲醛,仲通過過敏測試,適合初生嬰兒使用。靚叻媽聞落真係冇咩味,又厚又夠濕!

IMG_0256 copy

濕度:大力揸有2-3滴水出

厚度:star1star1star1star1star0 第二厚!

IMG_0239 copy

堅韌度:star1star1star1star1star0大大力都扯唔爛!

易抽度:star1star1star0star0star0抽一張一定會連住下一張

清潔度:star1star1star0star0star0要抹4下先可以清走污積

IMG_0241 copy

IMG_0244

清潔用途:適用於清潔臉部、嘴部及身體各部分

成分:75%以上天然棉及天然人造絲,蜂膠,天然薰衣草精油,山茶花萃取液,六次淨化純水 (不完整成分列表)

產地:韓國

購買地點:萬寧

3. 順順兒頂級嬰兒濕紙巾 Soondoongi LOHAS Baby Wet Tissue 70pcs 

標榜不含酒精、色素、化角香料、螢光漂白劑、甲醛,仲通過過敏測試,適合初生嬰兒使用,並獲得LOHAS 認證。靚叻媽聞落有少少香料味,不過就又厚又大張又夠濕!

IMG_0257 copy

濕度:大力揸埋有7滴水出黎

厚度:star1star1star1star1star1最厚!唔怕抹抹下阿B個pat會穿左!

IMG_0248

堅韌度:star1star1star1star1star0大大力都扯唔爛!

易抽度:star1star1star0star0star0抽一張一定會連住下一張

清潔度:star1star1star0star0star0要抹4下先可以清走污積

IMG_0249 copy

IMG_0250 copy

清潔用途:清潔臉部、嘴部及身體各部分

成分:100%人造絲,有機荷荷芭油,植物性角鯊烷,山茶花萃取液,六次淨化純水(不完整成分列表)

產地:韓國

購買地點:萬寧

4.來來寶純水柔濕巾Lullaby Pure Water Baby Wipes 30pcs

標榜有3D立體圓點設計,緊貼寶寶肌膚,容易清潔。使用優質純水配合超柔軟棉布製成,不含酒精,不含香料,經SGS測試。聞落冇咩味,同埋鎖水力強!

IMG_0255 copy

濕度:大力揸有2滴水出

厚度:star1star1star1star0第四厚!望落多細窿

IMG_0251 copy

堅韌度:star1star1star1star1star1延展度最低+大大力都扯唔爛!

易抽度:star1star1star1star1star1一張過抽出黎!乾淨利落!

清潔度:star1star1star1star1star1抹2下就可以清走污積

IMG_0252 copy

IMG_0254

清潔用途:清潔寶寶身體各處

成分:Purified water, non-woven, anti-bacteria reagent(不完整成分列表)

產地:台灣

購買地點:網上訂購、BB用品鋪

5.萬寧嬰兒柔濕巾 Mannings Baby Wipes 90pcs

標榜無酒精,含蘆薈及維生素E,立體蜂巢細孔軟墊更具潔淨功效。朋友推介我用萬寧牌濕紙巾幫BB抹Pat Pat,因為超級平!但我睇見佢有咁多防腐劑,真係唔夠膽比阿B用呀!同埋佢個蓋要用暴力先閂得埋…e10

IMG_0258

濕度:大力揸埋好多水咇出黎呀!(我自己就唔鐘意太濕,抹完阿B個pat又要再用紙巾抹返乾!)

厚度:star1star1star0star0star0最薄!!就咁望落都好多窿!

IMG_0260 copy

堅韌度:star1star0star0star0star0延展度高,但會扯得爛

易抽度:star1star1star0star0star0抽一張一定會連住下一張

清潔度:star1star1star1star1star0抹3下先可以清走污積

IMG_0261 copy

IMG_0262 copy

清潔用途:一般清潔用途

成分:non-woven fabric, aqua, polysorbate 20, phenoxyethanol,  methylparaben, ethylparaben, butylparaben, propylparaben, isobutylparaben, aloe barbadensis leaf juice, 2-bromo-2-nitropropane-1, 3-diol, tocopheryl aceate

產地:台灣

購買地點:萬寧

6. HUGGIES天然加厚嬰兒濕紙巾 Thick Baby Wipes 80pcs

標榜不含MIT及Paraben,無酒精及香料,含蘆薈及維生素E 成份。好多媽媽朋友推薦我用嫁!之前消委會調查發現HUGGIES濕紙巾有MIT同Paraben防腐劑,但宜家冇左啦,轉左用Phenoxyethanol防腐劑,都係對BB唔好,都係有d擔心!e7

IMG_0268 copy

濕度:大力揸埋冇水咇出黎!但都夠抹走d污積嘅

厚度:star1star1star1star1star0第三厚!

IMG_0269

最厚嘅位同順順兒深綠色差唔多,但因為有d花紋位,令到整體感覺薄左

堅韌度:star0star0star0star0star0一扯就會爛,不過用黎抹patpat溫柔d都唔會穿嘅,勝在夠厚~

有d媽媽話係易撕爛嘅設計係因為HUGGIES濕紙巾可沖落廁所同埋可分解,但係靚叻媽係包裝到搵唔到可分解3個字,反而見到….

IMG_0350

但有時淨係想要個角仔抹下野,易撕呢方面都幾好嘅!

易抽度:star1star1star1star0star0

如果淨係抽個角好易抽爛,但抽出黎一張過唔會拖泥帶水!

清潔度:star1star1star0star0star0抹5下先可以清走污積

IMG_0273 copy

IMG_0274 copy

清潔用途:清潔嬰兒屁股/多用途的產品

成分:Water, Phenoxyethanol, Amodimethicone, Aloe Barbadensis Leaf Extract, Caprylyl Glycol, Cocamidopropyl Bataine, Malic Acid, Sodium Citrate, Tocopheryl Acetate (Vitamin E is in the form of Tocopheryl Acetate)

產地:美國

購買地點:萬寧、屈臣氏、各大藥房

參考資料:消委會檢視44款嬰幼兒清潔濕巾的產品資料 (2014年09月)