【產品測試】Goo.N、Huggies、Pampers、Merries – 2017紙尿片大比拼!

【產品測試】Goo.N、Huggies、Pampers、Merries – 2017紙尿片大比拼!


除咗媽咪爸比之外,尿片已經係BB們嘅摯親~正因為咁,我知道好多新手媽咪都為緊BB嘅片片頭痕⋯⋯今日!Testingmama就為大家上演2017年度嘅尿片大比拼

測試尿片牌子: Goo.N、Huggies、Pampers、Merries

測試尺寸:L碼

4-diapers

Round 1 -吸水速度

BB最無忍耐力,一急起嚟就會BoomBoomBoom一發不可收拾,仲難忍過老闆(唔係我嗰個)啲脾氣!所以Testingmama首先會為大家做個吸水速度測試~

方法:將試管放喺尿片上面,再分別倒入250ML 含色素嘅熱水,模擬返BB一晚嘅尿量,計時至尿片全部吸收,睇下邊隻牌子用嘅時間最短

Speed-test-new-

結果:

Goo.N :  00:39.13   star1star0star0star0
Huggies :  00:37.09   star1star1star0star0
Pampers :   00:11.67   star1star1star1star1     Win!
Merries :  00:22.08   star1star1star1star0

Round 2 -均勻吸水力

之但係吸得快,如果唔夠均勻都會減弱尿片嘅戰鬥力㗎!接住落嚟我地會跟進下啲Weewee 嘅吸收範圍!如果 Weewee 面積愈廣愈分散,咁就無咁up住BB pat pat啦。

Area

結果:

Goo.N:   約16cm x 9.5cm     star1star0star0star0
Huggies:  約17cm x 9.5cm      star1star1star0star0
Pampers:  約19cm x 10.5cm  star1star1star1star0
Merries:  約21.5cm x 9.5cm  star1star1star1star1      Win!

好明顯Pampers同Merries都比較分散,但Merries係再大範圍少少,所以今Round Merries險勝!

Round 3 -防回滲力

媽媽好怕片片似回力標咁,你畀幾多佢,佢又畀返咁多你(冏),成日up住仲可能會有尿布疹!

方法:喺尿片吸水後等30秒,放上一片紙巾,再放一舊鉛喺托盤上面施加壓力,計時5秒就拎開舊鉛,檢視紙巾沾濕範圍及程度,水痕愈少呢就即係愈乾爽,愈能夠防止回滲~

Pressure-method

結果:

Pressure-result-

Goo.N:        star1star1star1star0
Huggies:     star1star1star0star0
Pampers:    star1star1star1star1     Win!
Merries:      star1star0star0star0

Merries喺呢次測驗入面係最禮尚往來嘅片片,而Huggies比起第二名嘅Goon.N回滲多少少,所以Pampers就係四隻牌子入面最防滲嘅尿片喇。

Round 4 - 透氣度

啲尿片嘅透氣度都好重要㗎。BB個屁股零舍敏感,如果片片透氣度唔夠,隨時股都紅哂。

方法:宜家我會模仿Weewee溫度,喺尿片上倒250ml 37°C溫水,然後用紅外線溫度計分別量度片芯同尿片背面嘅溫度。如果片外面最高溫、而片芯最低溫,就代表佢散熱速度最快之餘,又唔會散返去BB Pat Pat 嗰度~

結果:

片芯溫度:

Temperature-Inside(new)

Goo.N:   34.1°C     star1star1star1star0
Huggies :  34.8°C   star1star0star0star0
Pampers :  30.4°C  star1star1star1star1     Win!
Merries :  34.7°C    star1star1star0star0

片外溫度:

Temperature-Outside-

Goo.N  32.9°C          star1star1star0star0
Huggies  32.8°C       star1star0star0star0
Pampers   34.2°C      star1star1star1star1     Win!
Merries     33.5°C       star1star1star1star0

Round 5 - 吸水量

呢個回合我地睇下吸水量。將尿片浸喺水度1分鐘,再比較前後重量增加咗幾多,咁就即係吸咗幾多Weewee喇~

Weight

結果:

Goo.N  +1150g            star1star1star1star1     Win!
Huggies  +1140g        star1star1star1star0
Pampers   + ~800 g   star1star0star0star0
Merries   +1110g         star1star1star0star0

大家都見到Goo.N多咗成1120克Weewee,贏咗吸水量!Merries同Huggies嘅吸水量都差唔多,呢個回合Pampers稍為遜色喇。

不過~BB啲Weewee都唔係取之不盡嘅,BB一晚嘅尿量大約250ML,盡其量都係三百克左右,所以如果知道BB本身唔係大水喉都唔使咁擔心~

Round 6 - 柔軟度

嚟到最後一Round喇!BB成日郁嚟郁去,尿片作為BB嘅親密摯友,等Testingmama摸過佢地夠唔夠體貼啦!

Touch

先睇下Goo.N,佢表面比較粗糙,同有啲薄身,較少內裡棉軟軟嘅感覺~

Huggies呢,整體都比較平滑柔軟,雖然表面有一粒粒嘅3d透氣層,摸上去會覺得凹凹凸凸,但都係好柔軟。

至於Pampers呢,佢表面平滑柔軟,但兩邊嘅橡筋箍位都比較緊同有少少凹凸感。

最後係Merries,感覺唔算平滑,不過不失啦。由於呢個回合都帶主觀成份,所以我就唔作評分喇~

總結:

不如等我再為咁多位精明媽媽快速睇下呢四款尿片嘅基本資料做個補充啦~!

Chart1 copy

再回顧返今次片片大比拼嘅總結表啦~

Chart2 copy

Testingmama知道~揀尿片同揀奶粉一樣,用邊隻、好唔好用都要睇返自己BB嘅體型同膚質~所以我都建議媽媽們可以拎多D唔同牌子尿片嘅試用裝試下先!咁就可以搵

到同寶寶最岩Key嘅片片啦~下次再同大家比拼其他產品啦,bye-bye!